The double-slit experiment
Fire particles one at a time through two slits. They make a wave pattern. Watch them and the pattern vanishes.
Thomas Young with light, 1801; single electrons, Akira Tonomura's team, 1989
The electron that went both ways
In 1801 Thomas Young shone light through two narrow slits onto a screen. Instead of two bright lines, he saw many stripes, light and dark. That is the signature of waves: where the waves from the two slits meet crest to crest they add up, and where crest meets trough they cancel.
Nearly two hundred years later, in 1989, Akira Tonomura and his team at Hitachi in Japan did something even stranger. They fired electrons, tiny particles, through a double slit one at a time. Each electron landed as a single dot on the screen, exactly like a particle.
But as thousands of dots built up, the same stripes appeared. Each electron, travelling alone, seemed to have gone through both slits and interfered with itself.
So the scientists put a detector at the slits to catch each electron in the act and see which slit it really used. The moment they did, the stripes disappeared. Just two plain bands, as if the electrons knew they were being watched.
The puzzle
A single particle behaves as if it passed through both slits, unless you check which slit it took.
See it for yourself
What's really going on
In quantum mechanics, a particle is described by a wave of possibilities. Both paths contribute to that wave, and the two parts interfere, setting where the particle is likely to land. Any measurement that tells you which slit it used gets that information from the electron and destroys the interference, so you get two bands.
'Watching' doesn't need a person: any interaction that leaves a record of the path will do it. The experiment has been done with photons, electrons, atoms and even large molecules of 2,000 atoms. What the particle is 'really' doing between the source and the screen depends on which interpretation of quantum mechanics you prefer.
Still argued about. The results are certain and have been repeated countless times; what they mean is still argued about.
Think about it
Richard Feynman said this experiment contains 'the only mystery' of quantum mechanics. Why do you think he said that?
More physics paradoxes
- Schrödinger's catA cat in a box is both alive and dead until someone looks. Really?
- Maxwell's demonA tiny demon opens a door and makes heat flow backwards. Free energy forever?
- The black hole information paradoxThrow a book into a black hole. When the hole evaporates, is the book's information gone forever?